ICOs in Hong Kong: a New Way Out? (Part One: What is an ICO)

With the rise of blockchain technology in recent years and the surge in prices of cryptocurrencies in 2017, initial coin offerings (ICOs) have taken investors (both institutional and private) worldwide by the storm.

Many start-ups (especially tech-related businesses) have been drawn to ICOs, not only because of their openness, but because they require fewer sophisticated resources and procedures compared to the traditional fund-raising methods.

What Is an ICO and How it Works

For an ICO, the issuer creates “tokens” (in the form of intangible cryptocurrency). Tokens are then offered for sale through a blockchain (a decentralised digital ledger).

Among investors, an ICO is often compared to an IPO (initial public offering). But although they do share some commonalities, the former is much more versatile because its use is not limited to capital-raising.

There are 2 major types of tokens that can be issued in an ICO:

  • Security (or speculative) tokens: Akin to stocks in an IPO, security tokens are sold to the general public, in exchange for either fiat money or other pre-existing cryptocurrency, in order to raise capital. Investors may then freely trade their tokens on cryptocurrency platforms or cash out.

Science Blockchain, which incubates blockchain and cryptocurrency-related businesses, is one of the most notable companies that used an ICO to offer security tokens. The ICO raised over $12 million USD for the company.

  • Utility tokens: As opposed to security tokens, utility tokens are not designed for investments, but are offered as a form of pre-sale of a commodity. Holders are entitled to redeem products or services offered by the issuer at a later time. These tokens are often issued in an ICO for crowdfunding purposes, since they allow budding businesses to raise funds in a short time.

Bankera, which gives token-holders access to their decentralised banking services, raised more than $100 million USD during their crowd sale.

Opportunities and Risks

Blockchain technology and ICOs undoubtedly possess great potential, and there is no lack of successful ICOs.

Nonetheless, failed cases do exist. Moreover, regulations in different jurisdictions vary significantly. Since ICOs are still in the stage of constant development, even the laws within a jurisdiction may occasionally change.

Accordingly, interested investors and institutions planning to launch an ICO are reminded to always keep an eye on relevant existing regulations and the introduction of new regulatory regimes. They should ensure that they are fully aware of and prepared for the potential risks.

The information provided here is intended to give general information only. It is not a complete statement of the law. It is not intended to be relied upon or to be a substitute for legal advice in relation to particular circumstances.

Jurisdictions: 

Solicitor, Hong Kong Qualified 

Joshua Chu is Litigation Solicitor qualified to practice in Hong Kong. Before becoming a lawyer, Joshua worked in the healthcare industry serving as the IT department head at a private hospital as well as overseeing their procurement operations.

His legal experience includes representing the successful party in one of Hong Kong’s first cryptocurrency litigation cases as well as appearing before the Review Body on Bid Challenges under the World Trade Organization Government Procurement Agreement concerning a health care industry related tender.

On the side, Joshua has also dabbled into academic, regulatory, compliance and business consultancy practices where he maximize the utility of his past technical experiences. 

Barrister, Hong Kong

Moses served as a naval officer in the Korean Navy for almost 4 years before reading law and qualifying as a barrister (trial lawyer) in Hong Kong.

He is in private practice focusing on cross-border commercial litigation and arbitration. Moses’ practice covers a broad spectrum of commercial work with an emphasis on civil fraud, asset-tracing/recovery, enforcement of foreign arbitral awards and judgments, securities and investment products as well as construction litigation and arbitration. He has a particular specialty in multi-jurisdictional disputes involving international parties and matters with a cross-border element.